This forum uses cookies
This forum makes use of cookies to store your login information if you are registered, and your last visit if you are not. Cookies are small text documents stored on your computer; the cookies set by this forum can only be used on this website and pose no security risk. Cookies on this forum also track the specific topics you have read and when you last read them. Please confirm whether you accept or reject these cookies being set.

A cookie will be stored in your browser regardless of choice to prevent you being asked this question again. You will be able to change your cookie settings at any time using the link in the footer.

[BUG] NVEnc h.265 - adaptive quantization scheint nicht zu funktionieren
#10
PRESET QUALITY:

[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 13][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 2][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 6991.40 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 03][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 2][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 6991.40 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 01][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 2][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 6991.40 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 00][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 2][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 6991.40 kbps

[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 13][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 2][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 7746.09 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 03][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 2][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 7746.09 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 01][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 2][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 7746.09 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 00][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 2][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 7746.09 kbps

[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 13][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 1][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 6984.23 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 03][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 1][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 6984.23 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 01][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 1][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 6984.23 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 00][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 1][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 6984.23 kbps

[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 13][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 1][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 8004.16 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 03][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 1][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 8004.16 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 01][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 1][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 8004.16 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 00][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 1][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 8004.16 kbps

[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 13][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 0][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 11830.25 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 03][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 0][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 7046.49 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 01][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 0][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 5926.45 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 00][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 0][tf-level 4][lookahead 32] -> 9508.85 kbps

[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 13][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 0][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 15583.77 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 03][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 0][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 10368.66 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 00][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 0][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 13042.10 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][aq-strength 01][aq-temporal][lookahead-level 0][tf-level 0][lookahead 32] -> 9287.33 kbps


[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][lookahead-level 1][tf-level 0][lookahead 32]                              -> 8004.16 kbps
[VBR27.5][preset quality][REF5_5_2][BF4][lookahead-level 2][tf-level 0][lookahead 32]                              -> 7746.09 kbps

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Bei PRESET DEFAULT verhält es sich ganz genauso, kein Unterschied wie anfangs angenommen und tf-level hat auch keinen Einfluss.
Einzig lookahead-level 1 und 2 scheinen adaptive quantisation auszuhebeln.

Sieht irgendwie schwer nach Bug aus, es sei denn die höheren lookahead level können Wasser zu Wein machen, und erreichen, wenn tf-level ausgeschaltet/auf 0 ist, bei gleichbleibender Qualität Bitraten, die lookahead-level 1/2 nichtmal mit aq-strength 1 erreichen und machen adaptive quantisation überflüssig...


Attached Files
.7z   PRESET QUALITY.7z (Size: 5,37 KB / Downloads: 7)
.7z   NVENCC_TEST_AQ_OFF.7z (Size: 1,88 KB / Downloads: 7)
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: NVEnc h.265 - adaptive quantization scheint nicht zu funktionieren - by mogobime - 10.06.2026, 01:39

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)