issue with adding multiple audio tracks on dvd

[petrus]

Hi. I seem to have an issue with reading DVD-Input and multiple audio-streams on the DVD.
For example, my DVD has 2 audio streams, the first stream is #139 and contains DTS 5.1 Audio. 
The second stream is #160 and contains a LPCM audiostream.

When I select "Audio: auto add all" in the Base tab, Hybrid adds 1 stream under Audio, containing 2 audio-streams in 1 line (so without Enter) :

F:\VIDEO_TS;160;dts;6;passthrough;754;;;48000;;en;0;5965.48;dts;0;;don't change;;false;;false;2;false;;;;false;false;;;false;48000;unknown;dts;;false;true;false;;1/1;;;;01;None;;;;;;24;;;;false;1;;;;;;;;;;;;6;false;F:\VIDEO_TS;true;false;;;;6;;;-1;; :*: F:\VIDEO_TS;137;dts;6;passthrough;754;;;48000;;en;0;5965.48;dts;1;;don't change;;false;;false;2;false;;;;false;false;;;false;48000;unknown;dts;;false;true;false;;1/1;;;;01;None;;;;;;24;;;;false;2;;;;;;;;;;;;6;false;F:\VIDEO_TS;true;false;;;;6;;;-1;;

   

The strange thing is, that both streams are read as DTS, the audio-type of the 1st stream. This issue occurs also when deleting the entry above and add both tracks seperately:

   

I can reproduce this issue for 3 dvd's, so it look likes hybrid add the correct amount of audio-tracks, but copies the stream info of the first audio-track to all the tracks.

I'm currently using Hybrid_dev_2025.01.25-183659

Please let me know if you need more info or logs.


Media Info data:

   

[Selur]

Without a debug output, I can't tell where the issue originates from.
Might be an issue with the analysis or the 'audio job entry creation'.
If you are unsure on how to properly create a debug output, read the sticky about 'Infos needed to fix&reproduce bugs,..'.

Cu Selur

Ps.: As a workaround: remuxing the DVD to mkv beforehand should work.

[petrus]

Okay, I understand.

I've attached the debug file as well the report file in the attachment.

 
  logging.zip (Size: 33,4 KB / Downloads: 6)

[Selur]

That debug output doesn't contain the analysis of the source.
I need a debug output that:
a. contains the analysis of the source
b. the job creation
I don't need the job processing.
=> please, re-read the sticky.

Cu elur

[petrus]

Thanks for your reply. I've attached the logging to this reply.


  HybridDebugOutput.zip (Size: 71,83 KB / Downloads: 7)

[Selur]

Okay, problems seems to be with the analysis.
Can you share one of the vob files of your source? Will need a sample to debug this.

Cu Selur

[petrus]

Strange thing is that, when I select a .vob as single file (and do NOT select DVD Input), the analysis seems to work fine.

And sure, you can have a .vob, will send you a link in a PM. Thanks

[Selur]

Argh, okay in that case the vob file won't help.
I'll have to think about how I can reproduce this here somehow, but non of my DVDs I got on hdd has such a audio stream combination. Will have to scour some old backups to see if I can find some old dvd backup of a disc which allows me to reproduce this.
=> this probably won't be fixed any time soon, so your best course of action would be to not use the dvd input.

Cu Selur

[petrus]

It would be no problem to work around this with selecting a .vob file. But it random works for some dvd's, other dvd's won't. So I decided to report this issue 
If it does help to provide you with a 'testdvd' for testing, please let me know. For now I work around with seperate video and audio streams.

[Selur]

Sure, if you can provide a testdvd that would help.

Cu Selur